Skip NavigationSkip Main

by

Alex Borg

Share to Social

Copied!

May 2, 2024

3 minute read

Fleet Management Blog

3 Reasons for Rising Car Insurance Premiums

If you’ve been keeping an eye on your fleet’s expenses, you’ve probably noticed an unwelcome change in your insurance premiums lately. Here’s what’s causing insurance costs to climb all of a sudden.

3 Reasons for Rising Car Insurance Premiums

Across the US, car insurance costs have been skyrocketing over the past few months. Compared to what they were in March 2023, rates were up by 22.2% percent last month according to the most recent Consumer Price Index. To put that into perspective, economists haven't seen a year-over-year spike that severe since 1976.

These climbing insurance rates stand out at a time when inflation has largely calmed and the cost of things like fuel and parts have stabilized. While those other expenses are also pricier than they once were (primarily due to post-pandemic inflation), economists aren't expecting them to surge over the course of 2024. The same can't be said about fleet insurance costs.

So why have insurance prices been going through the roof lately? Here are the biggest reasons:

1. More frequent accidents

If you've ever felt like people have been driving more recklessly over the past few years, it might be gratifying to learn that telematics data supports your hunch. Cambridge Mobile Telematics (CMT), a company that describes itself as "the world's largest telematics service provider," tracks how millions of drivers behave behind the wheel for usage-based insurance programs. By reviewing the data their apps collect, CMT has observed a dramatic uptick in distracted driving behaviors since COVID-19 upended the world.

And since around 2020, both the frequency of serious vehicle accidents and the severity of the average auto insurance claim have increased substantially in the US. In response to their customers' vehicles suffering greater amounts of damage more often, fleet insurance providers argue that increasing their rates is a necessary means of adapting to a new normal.

Did you know?

Things might be taking a turn for the better when it comes to Americans paying attention behind the wheel. According to a recent report by CMT, distracted driving in the US fell by 4.5% in 2023. While distracted driving levels are still higher than they were in 2020, this is the first decrease the company has observed since the pandemic.

Assess your operations with fleet management reports

Fleetio provides a wide variety of customizable reports to help organizations monitor their operating costs, vehicle utilization and performance metrics. By surfacing valuable insights, these reports help fleets optimize their operations.

Learn more

2. Increased repair costs

For the past couple years now, getting a good deal on a vehicle has been an uphill battle. During the pandemic, factory closures and supply chain disruptions resulted in historically low inventory levels, which, in turn, caused vehicle prices to spike. When the worst of COVID-19 was finally behind us, inflation soon reached historic highs, and vehicle prices followed suit. Even now that inflation has largely settled, car prices are notably higher than they were just a few years back.

As one might expect, this increase in car prices (and the parts they rely on) has had a knock-on effect on maintaining and repairing fleet company vehicles. Working on vehicles is simply more expensive these days, and as a result, insurance providers have raised their rates to offset their increased expenses.

3. Extreme weather

Mother Nature put America through the wringer throughout 2023. By the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's count, 28 weather and climate disasters afflicted the US last year. Combined, those floods, tornados and other severe weather events caused at least $92.9 billion in damages.

Consequently, many insurance companies ended up paying out signficantly more in catastrophic claims than in years prior. According to the Insurance Information Institute (III), in 2023, insurers on average paid out more than $1.10 for every $1 premium they collected.

To compensate for those losses, fleet insurance providers have raised their rates in recent months. In a comment to National Public Radio, III's CEO said "Nobody wants to have that higher-price bill," but added that companies "need to price insurance according to the risk level that's out there."


If learning about the forces that influence car insurance costs has left you feeling powerless, don't despair. Remember that there are ways for you to lower your insurance costs (and improve the health of your assets and the safety of your fleet drivers in the process).

Discover why fleets choose Fleetio

Thousands of organizations across countless industries rely on Fleetio to manage their fleet activities. No matter the size of your fleet, Fleetio can help you track, analyze and improve your operations.

Book a demo

About the Author


Alex Borg

Alex Borg

Content Marketing Specialist

Alex Borg is a Content Marketing Specialist at Fleetio. Beyond writing, his interests include going to concerts, playing guitar, and hanging out at the beach.

Ready to get started?

Join thousands of satisfied customers using Fleetio

Questions? Call us at 1-800-975-5304