How to Navigate the Current Trucking & Freight Challenges

Key takeaways from this article

1. Overcapacity and rate pressure are undermining profitability: The trucking and freight industry is experiencing excess fleet capacity and declining spot-rates, which is squeezing margins and delaying market recovery.

2. Operating costs remain high and volatile: Key cost drivers — fuel, tires, maintenance — are elevated, making cost-control and efficiency critical to sustain operations in the current market environment.

3. Driver shortages and retention headwinds persist: Recruiting and keeping skilled drivers remain major pain points, with high turnover and rising retention costs threatening operational stability.

4. 2025 critical issues are reshaping fleet priorities: According to ATRI’s 2025 Top Industry Issues report, economic pressure remains fleets’ top concern, followed by rising legal and insurance costs. Persistent driver-related challenges continue to dominate, while new concerns point to a rapidly modernizing and compliance-heavy future.

5. Strategic fleet management is a must for navigating uncertainty: Fleets that proactively right-size capacity, optimize cost structures and invest in driver retention are better positioned to weather the downturn and pivot when recovery gains momentum.

The trucking and freight industry has faced a number of challenges in recent years. Conflicts in the Middle East hindered access to the Suez Canal and the short-term dockworker strikes caused backups and delays in freight movement. On top of that, some experts even suggested that the industry was teetering on the edge of a recession due to capacity outweighing demand. So, what are current trucking industry trends and what could be on the horizon?

Top Issues in Trucking in 2025

In October 2025, the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) released its latest Top Industry Issues report, offering valuable insight into what’s shaping the future of trucking. The 2025 edition highlights several emerging and persistent trends that fleets should keep on their radar.

• Economic pressure remains high: For the third consecutive year, the economy ranks as the number one concern across the industry. Fleets are grappling with weak freight demand, falling spot rates and delayed equipment purchases as they navigate tighter margins.
• Rising legal and insurance costs: Lawsuit abuse reform and insurance availability climbed to the number two and three positions respectively in ATRI’s rankings. Expensive verdicts and litigation funding have made risk management a growing financial burden for carriers.
• Driver-focused challenges continue: While the driver shortage has stabilized somewhat, retention, compensation and parking availability remain top-five issues. These ongoing pain points continue to affect fleet performance and satisfaction.
• New issues on the horizon: ATRI identified several first-time concerns for 2025, including artificial intelligence in trucking, English language proficiency requirements and the upcoming 2027 diesel emissions regulations. These signal a shift toward modernization, compliance and workforce adaptability.

As the industry adapts to these challenges, fleets that centralize data, invest in driver experience and embrace technology for predictive maintenance and compliance tracking will be best positioned to stay competitive through 2025 and beyond.

How to Overcome Some of Trucking's Top Challenges

1. Overcapacity and Rate Declines

A trucking industry forecast for 2025 surfaced several issues to watch for. Throughout 2024, the industry grappled with overcapacity, which led to a decline in freight rates. “The freight market continues to be characterized by overcapacity, and with private fleets engaging in spot activity more than in past cycles, spot rates remain only slightly above the late-2023 lows,” according to ACT Research. “The Pricing Index ticked down 0.6 points in June to 47.9, remaining at close to neutral levels as freight rates continue to hover just above cycle low levels. Excess capacity additions by private fleets have extended this down cycle to the longest on record, as the scarring they incurred during the pandemic changed their tune on equipment purchases.” This put pressure on for-hire fleets, leading to the worst profitability in 14 years for publicly traded truckload carriers, and it's a problem that still persists today.

The Solution: Strengthen Capacity Management

To adapt to the challenge of overcapacity, fleets need to be strategic about managing their assets, specifically when it comes to rightsizing and determining optimal replacement windows to reduce or delay truck and equipment acquisitions. Doing so can potentially lead to an improvement in freight rates and a reduction in overhead costs.

2. Rising Operational Costs

The operational costs in the trucking industry have continued to rise, though some cost centers have seen an easing in 2024. The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), in their 2025 trucking cost breakdown, reported that trucking costs reached new heights in 2023, with the marginal cost of trucking hitting $2.270 per mile. “Carrier fuel and tire expenses were trending downward in Q1 2024 as were used Class 8 truck prices,” according to the report. “The repair and maintenance trends observed in 2023 persisted in early 2024 and point toward another year of only moderate increases in that cost center.” This year, economic pressure remain high, though costs constinue to ease incriminetally.

The Solution: Cost Control

As truck fleet operating costs fluctuate, fleets should focus on cost control, especially in the larger cost centers like fuel and maintenance. Leveraging trucking fleet software can help fleets implement fuel-efficient practices and optimize fleet-wide efficiency. The ability to collect robust data enables fleets to determine high-cost vs. value assets, ensures high inspection and maintenance compliance rates and can significantly reduce unnecessary downtime.

2025 Trucking Industry Forecast

Between a potential stabilization in the market and a rebalance of capacity issues, there’s a lot going on in the trucking world. Take a look at our 2025 Trucking Industry Forecast to evaluate how things are panning out.

Learn more

3. Driver Shortages and Retention

Driver shortages and retention challenges are proving an ongoing issue in the industry. “Many economists project the freight market to continue to soften in the first and second quarters of 2024 before rebounding in late 2024, so companies should remain focused on retaining their best employees,” according to Insurance Journal, which also lists rising cargo theft and DOT rule changes among its list of trucking challenges for 2024. “With turnover in some trucking industry segments as high as 85% to 90%, fleets have invested in retention bonuses to keep their best drivers. In fact, the average retention bonus has climbed almost 90% over the past four years to $1,272.” ATRI’s 2025 survey shows that driver compensation and retention remain top-of-mind; signaling a continuation of this issue.

The Solution: Invest in Employee Retention

Retaining skilled drivers is crucial, but making the company appealing to job seekers can provide a safety net in times of labor shortages. Fleets investing in retention strategies, such as offering competitive wages, benefits and bonuses, are likely to see a better outcome than those trying to cut costs in this area.

Onward and Upward

Trucking challenges remain top-of-mind for many in the industry, and the chaos of this year’s election is only adding fuel to the fire. The future always holds some level of uncertainty, so maximizing operational insights is key to keeping trucks on the road. Taking every advantage available to control costs and maintain efficiency and productivity can help ensure your fleet succeeds, especially during rough patches. Trucking fleet management and optimization platforms are a great way to dial into high-cost centers and inefficient processes.

While the trucking and freight industry is expected to face a mixed bag of challenges and opportunities, fleets that focus on strategic capacity management, cost control and driver retention will be better positioned to overcome these challenges and emerge stronger in the coming years.

See it. Track it. Fix it.

From long hauls to last-mile deliveries, Fleetio puts your entire operation in full view — all in one platform.

Here's how we do it